Energy

Energy case interviews address topics like renewable energy transition, oil & gas operations, utility restructuring, and sustainability strategy. These cases test your ability to analyze capital-intensive industries, regulatory environments, and long-term strategic planning.

Total Cases: 16
Companies: 2
Easy 1 Medium 13 Hard 2
Medium

Deepwater Inc

Investment Decision ROI Analysis Energy

Our client, Deepwater, is an oil refinery firm looking at an investment in a filtering unit to transform residual oil into useful feedstock to produce …

15 min
Chicago Booth
50
McKinsey
Medium

Electric Utility

Profitability Energy

Our client is GPE, a producer of electricity. Here are a few concepts about electricity generation that will help you in this case: • There are …

15 min
Chicago Booth
50
McKinsey
Medium

Renewable Diesel

Market Sizing Market Entry Energy

Seashell, one of the world's biggest oil and gas companies, has reached out to you to ask for help with an investment decision. They want to decide if …

15 min
Bauer
50
Medium

Wahoo Wind

Market Entry Profitability Energy

Your client, Wahoo Wind, builds windfarms in Texas, Iowa, and Oklahoma. The company is looking to expand into the growing offshore windfarm market on …

15 min
Darden
50
McKinsey
Hard

Climate change

Strategy Environmental Policy Overall economy

The government of a West European country Franland has been under international pressure recently to accelerate the decarbonization of its economy. …

15 min
PeterK
50
Hard

Dam Dam Dam

Non-Profit Energy

We have just been approached by the council of Dracula, an isolated city of 900,000 people. The council is considering whether to approve the request …

15 min
Columbia
50
Medium

EnerForce

Valuation M&A Energy

A U.S. energy conglomerate is considering the acquisition of a publicly traded wind turbine manufacturer, EnerForce, with manufacturing locations in …

15 min
NYU
50
McKinsey
Medium

Okay Mobile

Market Entry Telecom

Okay Mobile is an Australian provider of mobile phone plans and operates as a MVNO (Mobile Virtual Network Operator) on one of top-3 cellphone service …

15 min
PeterK
50
McKinsey
Medium

Premier Oil

Profitability Cost Reduction Oil & Gas

Given there is not much Premier Oil can do to increase sales, the manager wants us to focus on costs. To begin with, what are Premier Oil's major …

15 min
PeterK
50
McKinsey
Medium

PubU

Environmental Strategy Capital Investment Energy

You are the Dean of a large public university in the Midwest. Your tenure has focused on raising the profile of the university through various …

15 min
Darden
50
Medium

Utility Co.

Profitability Cost Reduction Energy

Our client is Utility Co., a US-based utility company that operates on the West Coast of the United States. Utility Co. has been profitable over the …

15 min
Duke
50
Easy

Bern Energy

Investment Analysis Cost-Benefit Analysis Energy

Your client, Bern Energy, is based in Southeast Asia and is one of the world's largest producers and suppliers of natural gas to major markets in Asia …

15 min
HKUST
50
Medium

GasCo Goes the Distance

Market Entry Profitability Oil & Gas

Your client is GasCo, a US-based natural gas company. In the last year, natural gas prices in the US have declined while prices in APAC and EMEA have …

15 min
ROSS
50
Medium

Harrison Energy EV Goals

Market Entry Strategy Power & Utilities

Our client, Harrison Energy, is one of the largest power & utilities companies in the US. You are in the year 2018, and the CEO sees electric vehicles …

15 min
ROSS
50
Medium

WolverineHomes

Profitability Risk Analysis Real Estate & Energy

WolverineHomes owns and manages over 200 single-family homes in the Ann Arbor, Ypsi, and Jackson areas. Recently, severe weather events have caused …

15 min
ROSS
50
McKinsey
Medium

PubU

Energy

15 min
Darden
50
  • Clean renewable energy sources like wind, solar, and biomass are increasingly utilized, with significant projected growth by 2050.
  • Technological advancements, particularly in ‘fracking’ and ‘horizontal drilling,’ have increased US oil output while reducing costs and risks.
  • New shale discoveries in the US have boosted domestic oil production, reducing reliance on foreign oil imports.
  • Natural gas is a primary energy source in the US due to its abundance and cost-effectiveness, displacing crude oil and coal.
  • Petroleum products include gasoline, jet fuel, natural gas, fertilizer, plastics, detergents, propane, diesel, and lubricants.

Important Terminology

  • Upstream (E&P): Exploration and Production – Activities involved in finding, drilling, and producing crude oil and natural gas (LNG).
  • Midstream: Focuses on the processing, storage, and transportation of oil and natural gas, often involving pipeline companies.
  • Downstream: Includes oil refineries, petrochemical plants, petroleum product distributors, retail outlets, and natural gas distribution companies.
  • OPEC (Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries): A cartel of 14 nations that coordinates petroleum policies, influencing global output and prices.

Important Calculations

  • Return on Investment (ROI): (Profits - Cost of Investment) / Cost of Investment
  • Breakeven Point: (Fixed Costs) / Contribution Margin (CM)

Important Considerations (Cost Drivers)

  • Transportation / Distribution costs
  • Storage Costs
  • Production Costs (Labor + Materials)
  • Plant Development Costs
  • Depreciation & Taxes
  • Overhead

Overview

  • Oil & Gas is a stage-based industry, with market share largely tied to upstream operations.
  • Upstream: Drilling and extracting raw oil (usually contracted out).
  • Midstream: Transporting the raw oil.
  • Downstream: Refining and selling the finished petroleum products.

Revenue Drivers

  • Upstream: Crude oil price.
  • Midstream: Transportation fees.
  • Downstream: Sale of gasoline, oils, fuel, and other petroleum products.

Cost Drivers

  • Upstream: Exploration costs (e.g., land leases).
  • Rig rates (daily usage) and rig utilization.
  • Drilling and extraction equipment & labor.
  • Midstream: Crude oil purchase.
  • Storage costs.
  • Transportation costs.
  • Pipeline construction.
  • Downstream: Crude oil purchase.
  • Refinery equipment & labor.
  • Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) accounts for ~44% of global oil production and ~73% of the world’s proven oil resources; OPEC effectively controls the price of oil.
  • Technology advancements (e.g., fracking) increase output and push costs down.
  • Liability for spills (environmental and safety risks).

Overview

  • Oil & Gas is a stage-based industry, with market share heavily linked to upstream operations.
  • Upstream operations involve drilling and extracting raw oil.
  • Midstream operations focus on transporting raw oil.
  • Downstream operations include refining and selling finished petroleum products.

Revenue Drivers

  • Upstream: Crude oil price.
  • Midstream: Transportation fees.
  • Downstream: Sale of gasoline, oils, fuel, and other petroleum products.

Cost Drivers

  • Upstream costs include exploration (e.g., land leases), rig rates and utilization, and drilling/extraction equipment and labor.
  • Midstream costs cover crude oil purchases, storage, transportation, and pipeline construction.
  • Downstream costs include crude oil purchases and refinery equipment and labor.
  • OPEC (Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries) controls approximately 44% of global oil production and 73% of proven oil resources, effectively influencing oil prices.
  • Technological advancements like fracking have increased output and reduced costs.
  • Significant liability risks associated with spills.
  • Requires extensive regulatory approval for operations.

Introduction

  • This industry deals with hydrocarbon extraction (upstream), transportation (midstream), and refinement (downstream).
  • It provides the most common precursors for fuel, plastics, and energy production.

Revenue Drivers

  • Upstream: Crude oil prices.
  • Midstream: Sales and purchase agreement contracts.
  • Downstream: Sales of refined products (e.g., gas, fuel, oils, plastic, lubricant).

Cost Drivers

  • Upstream: Exploration and extraction costs.
  • Midstream: Crude oil purchase, storage, and transport costs.
  • Downstream: Crude oil purchase and property, plant, and equipment (PP&E) costs.
  • Industry shifts towards sustainability and climate change awareness are exerting pressure.
  • The introduction of renewable energy can serve as a substitute for certain traditional oil and gas uses, but it faces technical challenges related to energy density (for jet fuel), chemical composition (for plastics), and other specific applications.
  • Significant price impacts on oil futures are observed due to post-pandemic recovery and geopolitical situations.

Suppliers

  • Land Surveyors
  • Government (for exploration permits)
  • Rig/equipment manufacturers

Customers

  • Finished goods manufacturers
  • Energy and fuel distributors
  • Power generators for transmission
  • Logistics and vehicle operators

Other Industry Metrics

  • Production (barrels): Quantity of oil or gas extracted.
  • Attainable reserve (barrels): Estimated amount of oil or gas that can be economically extracted.
  • Depletion rate: The rate at which natural resources are used up.
  • Carbon footprint: The total greenhouse gas emissions caused by an organization, event, product, or individual.

Major Regional Players in Asia

  • Sinopec
  • Saudi Aramco
  • China National Petroleum Corp.
  • China National Offshore Oil Corp.
  • ENEOS Corporation

Key Industry Ideas

  • The industry is segmented into upstream (exploration and production), midstream (transportation), and downstream (refining and marketing) operations.
  • Cost per gallon is a key metric.
  • Renewable energy sources are growing in importance.
  • Fracking (hydraulic fracturing) is a significant extraction method.

Important Terminology

  • PV-10: Present Value of estimated future net revenues from proved oil and gas reserves, discounted at 10% per year.
  • OPEC (Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries): An intergovernmental organization of 13 oil-exporting developing nations that coordinates petroleum policies of its members.

Revenue Streams

  • Sales of crude oil.
  • Sales of gasoline.
  • Sales of natural gas.
  • Revenue from refined products such as lubricants.
  • Income from gas stations, including fuel sales, convenience store items, and car washes.

Cost Drivers

  • Costs associated with exploration, including seismic studies, drilling rigs, and labor.
  • Expenses related to production, particularly refining.
  • Costs for pipelines used in transportation.
  • Operational costs for gas stations, including oil procurement, labor, insurance, and licenses.

Risks

  • Access to new oil and gas reserves.
  • Impact of energy policies and regulations.
  • Decisions made by OPEC regarding production levels.
  • Geopolitical pressures and instability.
  • Competition from substitute energy sources and growth of renewable energy.

Key Economic Drivers

  • Government regulation.
  • International oil production levels and global demand.

Customer Segments

  • Petroleum refiners.
  • Electricity generators.
  • Domestic and commercial consumers.
  • Other industrial sectors.

Channels

  • Retail sales.
  • Wholesale distribution.
  • Commercial sales.

Key Companies

  • Exxon Mobil
  • Baker Hughes
  • Saudi Aramco
  • Gazprom
  • Pemex
  • Phillips 66

Key Ideas

  • A highly cyclical industry driven by global supply-demand dynamics.
  • Capital-intensive exploration, production, and refining processes.
  • Prices are heavily influenced by OPEC decisions.
  • Requires significant upfront investment.
  • Subject to significant environmental, safety, and regulatory requirements.
  • Features an integrated value chain from upstream to downstream.
  • Large exposure to commodity price volatility.

Revenue

  • Crude oil production and sales.
  • Natural gas production and LNG exports.
  • Refined product sales (gasoline, diesel, jet fuel).
  • Petrochemicals and specialty chemical products.
  • Pipeline transport fees (midstream).
  • Trading and commodity hedging income.
  • Retail fuel station operations.

Costs

  • Fixed Costs: Exploration and drilling equipment, plant maintenance, pipelines and storage infrastructure, Corporate SG&A, and long-term regulatory obligations.
  • Variable Costs: Extraction costs, transportation and pipeline tariffs, labor for field operations, energy usage and water for drilling/refining, and repair costs.
  • Global shift toward decarbonization driving investment in renewables and lower-carbon fuels.
  • Increased LNG demand as countries transition away from coal.
  • Digital transformation is improving predictive maintenance and production efficiency.
  • Consolidation among operators as smaller players struggle with cost pressures.
  • Rising interest in carbon capture, utilization, and storage (CCUS) technologies.

Risks

  • Oil price volatility can cause large swings in profitability and capital spending.
  • Environmental and safety incidents can lead to severe financial and reputational damage.
  • Regulatory pressure around emissions, methane leaks, and ESG compliance is increasing.
  • Geopolitical instability in producing regions disrupts supply chains and pricing.
  • High capital intensity exposes companies to long payback periods and financing risk.

Key Industry Ideas

  • Increasing energy consumption.
  • Characterized by high investment costs and significant regulatory oversight.
  • Industry structure is evolving, with traditional utilities disintegrating into smaller supplier segments.
  • Operations are affected by seasonality.
  • Government incentives support sustainable initiatives.
  • Bundling of services with renewable energy options is becoming common.

Revenue Streams

  • Revenue from transmitted electricity, categorized into base load and intermittent sources.
  • Base load accounts for 95% of industry revenue, from sources like coal, natural gas, nuclear, and other traditional fuels.
  • Intermittent revenue generated from renewable energy sources.

Cost Drivers

  • Purchased power accounts, representing nearly half of total costs.
  • Infrastructure development and maintenance.
  • Wages and salaries.
  • Marketing expenses.
  • Maintenance contracts for equipment and systems.

Risks

  • The growth of clean energy poses a threat to traditional power generation methods.
  • Seasonal demand fluctuations lead to uncertain revenue and cost estimations.
  • Increased energy efficiency in appliances can decrease overall consumption.

Key Economic Drivers

  • Economies of scale.
  • Industrial production index.
  • Climate and seasonality impacts on demand.

Customer Segments

  • Commercial and industrial customers.
  • Residential customers.

Channels

  • Transmission lines and pipelines for distribution.
  • Upstream electricity generators.

Key Companies

  • PG&E
  • AES
  • Duke Energy
  • Exelon
  • National Grid
  • Nextera Energy