This is an open ended case. The interviewee needs to justify the recommendation based on the qualitative considerations
A good recommendation would include 3 sections:
Recommendation: If the recommendation is to outsource the interviewee needs to highlight the risks associated with outsourcing and nature of the acquired firm. If the recommendation uses any other approach sufficient justification needs to be given to overcome the cost savings
Risks:
- Risks associated with increasing capacity by more than 200% in the Philippines – people, infrastructure, service quality, gaps in knowledge transfer, organizational changes, etc.
- Reputational impact – do customers notice a difference in service, can the competitor leverage this to steal customers?
Next steps: If outsourcing, some of the next steps would be to analyze the infrastructure requirements and capabilities, find the right talent, ensure smooth transfer and implementation of best practices, etc.
The interviewee should explore the option of improving effectiveness of the Philippines location without being prompted
Excellent interviewees need to address the qualitative information provided in the case: nature of merger, nature of markets being served, etc.